Hear me out on this. The super 5* amazing players will go to the NFL, often before they have completed their 4 years. Some players try to go pro early, but don’t get drafted or don’t get that big money, losing their eligibility. THOSE players may be more inclined to stay in college if they’re making some money. Thoughts?
There may be positives to doing this, sure. But the net effect is going to be negative. I don’t think most college freshmen – especially those who come from poor families – are going to cope well with suddenly having lots of money. I see much more potential for off-field problems (drugs, partying, etc.).
For sure there will be negatives. How about student athletes getting agents? Lots of phony agents will be popping up and screwing naive athletes out of their money.
I’m super curious about how all of this is supposed to work. What’s to stop an Alabama car dealer from paying a 5-star Alabama QB recruit $1,000,000 to make a few “appearances” on behalf of the dealership? Where do they draw the line? Hell, I’m sure it’s already going on. If nothing else, at least it brings it above the table ;).
the SEC (surely ever cheating) lead the push for “greater autonomy” creating the idea of P-5 and G-5. They will always push the boundaries, even after caught cheating.