Are you really advocating taking a safety instead of risking a punt return for touchdown? Statistics aren’t going to support your strategy, I’m afraid.
A safety is worth 2 points, a TD worth 6. So you would have to be giving up a TD on 1 out of every 3 punts in order for you to “break even” with this strategy. This year, Utah has punted 33 times, and I believe there’s been 3 blocked or returned for TD? That’s 1 out of every 11 punts. We’ve given up 18 points on punt returns this year. If we had used your strategy, we would’ve given up 66 points, a net difference of -48 points which is -4 ppg.
I get it that you’re not happy with our special teams. I’m not either. But that would be an extreme overreaction.
There’s pessimism, there’s irrational pessimism, then there’s this idea.