you have to pay for it. PFF usually has a pretty good database. I don’t agree with all of their conclusions but that would be my first go-to.
Most places just show you counting stats which don’t have context to them. i.e. if you remember a few years back Evan Weaver at Cal was racking up the tackle stats. He even had around 20 against Utah in 2019 and the talking heads were doing their talking head thing. Not once did they mention that Utah was averaging around 8 yards a play when Weaver made the tackle. Instead, they just pointed to the counting stat as if he was dominant in that game.
Bill (I want to say Reilly but that doesn’t sound right) at ESPN who does SP+ also keeps a database from all of the play-by-plays from years past. I could go through the play-by-play from NCAA.com but I would (1) be starting from scratch (2) limited to the accuracy of the play call which typically only shows who touched the ball on O and who made the tackle, and (3) the relevant data from past seasons wouldn’t be available.
I’m not arguing that Johnson is better than Phillips as they are pretty much 1A and 1B with McCain/Smith in the conversation. My only point is that Interceptions and Pick-6’s are not always indicative of quality CB play. The Pick-6 Phillips has against WSU in 2021 came from the QB throwing a dig route while the receiver ran a stop and go. Phillips read the QB and squatted on the dig and it worked but we’ve also seen times where he has guessed wrong for huge gains against. And I don’t think Oregon State would have continued throwing against 2019 Johnson like they did 2022 Phillips which resulted in 4 picks (3 Phillips, 1 Hubert).
Utah @ 
UCF 
.
