I disagree. I’d rather go with Johnson.
Look at Barnes’ drives:
1 play, 70 yards. Great play by Barnes. Would have been there (probably more so) with Johnson, as the defense probably bites harder on the play action to start the game if Johnson was in.
7 plays, 36 yards, punt.
3 plays, 4 yards. punt.
7 plays, 14 yards, 3 points.
5 plays, 23 yards, punt.
3 plays, 11 yards, TD.
3 plays, -10 yards, punt.
Look at Johnson:
10 plays, 80 yards – TD
3 plays, 6 yards – punt
3 plays, -5 yards, punt.
7 plays, 38 yards, missed FG.
The offense moved the ball a lot better when Johnson was in, and even Barnes’ two TD’s weren’t really any testament to Barnes. It was a great play call to start the game and the other was off a turnover, and Johnson showed that he could have scored from 11 yards out.
Barnes is safe and I don’t say that in a good way.
If I’m the coaches, I do the same thing against Baylor that I did vs Florida, but with a little more Johnson. Then I have Johnson play the whole game against Weber St (unless you want to give Rising a couple drives) and then hope Rising is ready by UCLA.
But we know what Barnes is, and it isn’t good enough.