Few projections have Boise State with 1st Round Bye

This topic has 12 replies, 11 voices, and was last updated 1 month ago by Utah#1.

Viewing 7 reply threads

Author

Posts
- 10/21/2024 at 8:58 AM #229761
  4
  
  Ted Lasso
  Participant
  
  I’ve seen some projections that have Boise State being the 4 seed and getting the first round bye over the Big 12 champion, whether that be BYU, Colorado, Kansas State, or Iowa State. I would be pretty p**sed from a Big 12 standpoint if that were to happen, because we all know that playing a power 4 schedule is way different than playing a mountain west schedule. I do think Boise State might be better than any team the Big 12 has, but I don’t think Boise State would have the depth to get through a Big 12 schedule.
  
  I know you guys would find it hilarious if they did put Boise State ahead of BYU and I get it, but for the future of the Big 12 conference, I hope a precedence isn’t set here. I highly doubt it would happen but it’s possible. If Boise State had beaten Oregon, I might feel differently.
- 10/21/2024 at 9:09 AM #229764
  1 5
  
  Jim Vanderhoof
  Participant
  
  Top four seeds are P4 conference champions. No way Boise can be a top 4 ahead of Big12 champ or any other P4 champ.
  - 10/21/2024 at 9:12 AM #229765
    4
    
    Ted Lasso
    Participant
    
    If I’m not mistaken, I’m pretty sure the top 4 seeds are the highest ranked conference champions. So a G5 conference champion can still get a 1st Round Bye if they are ranked higher than a P4 champion.
    - 10/21/2024 at 9:13 AM #229766
      4
      
      NarfUte
      Participant
      
      Lasso is correct. Top-5 highest ranked conference champions make it, and the top-4 ranked conference champions get the top 4 seeds regardless of P4 vs. G5(6). So, theoretically the MWC champ could be ranked higher than the lowest P4 champ.
- 10/21/2024 at 9:20 AM #229769
  
  Rick Walker
  Participant
  
  I’ve been thinking this was a possibility for awhile now. Anyone in the big 12 loses and Boise state wins out then Boise probably gets the 4 seed. It basically comes down to if BYU Iowa state can stay undefeated or Kansas state can smoke everyone remaining on their schedule because Boise States 3 point loss to Oregon is gonna be better than any loss anyone in the Big12 has.
- 10/21/2024 at 9:48 AM #229776
  1
  
  Charlie Foxtrot
  Participant
  
  This is the problem with a system where the best teams from either the Big 12 or ACC start the season unranked or barely in the top 25. The B1G or SEC don’t need to worry about having their conference champions bumped for a G5 but the Big 12 and ACC certainly do.
  
  If Boise St. does get a 1st round bye then I hope they get matched up against a B1G or SEC team and take them out in the second round.
- 10/21/2024 at 10:21 AM #229787
  1
  
  SalUteopia
  Participant
  
  What is this playoff thingy you’re talking about, Ted? Must be nice to be a premium team.. 😞
  - 10/21/2024 at 10:36 AM #229795
    
    Ted Lasso
    Participant
    
    Haha I don’t feel bad for you guys at all, you’ve had enough fun the last 3-4 years 😉 And BYU will find a way to choke. It’s statistically likely.
    - 10/21/2024 at 10:55 AM #229797
      
      Kellso
      Participant
      
      It would be a sad day in football if BS gets the first round bye over a Big12 champ. I don’t care who it is.
    - 10/21/2024 at 11:51 AM #229824
      1
      
      RoboUte
      Participant
      
      lol. Well they may not win but getting the opportunity is all you can ask for. One step at a time. And you just may capitalize on that opportunity.
- 10/21/2024 at 11:45 AM #229817
  2
  
  2008 National Champ
  Participant
  
  In the middle of a major coaching change you want to discuss why a different team than Utah should be unhappy if they get snubbed for another team not named Utah?
- 10/21/2024 at 1:29 PM #229859
  
  RedUte14
  Participant
  
  Utah fans hate boise state almost as much as BYU. so i think most of us would hate to see that.
- 10/21/2024 at 2:56 PM #229885
  
  Utah#1
  Participant
  
  You should already know why? They don’t respect anyone else in the Big12 outside of Utah which was projected a pre-season #4 seed in the CFP until they F’d that up, yet again! The powers that be, think BYU is not as good as their record shows (kinda agree with them…) or even worthy to be in the same conversation as the top 10 regardless of one loss, and why it took them as long to become a member of a P4. No one wanted them, and IMO still don’t. I think even if they finish top 10 in the CFP rankings, CFP committee could leave them out and include other undefeated teams in the top 25 not named BYU.
  
  Do they deserve to be selected for a CFP berth if they are still undefeated when the selections are decided? Yes, I do; but is their schedule kinda soft and will they probably get destroyed by a top 10 team, I think they would, but who knows.
Author

Posts