It seems unfair to give it to just one of Shelley, Shyne, or Gay. If Shelley doesn’t come in and play like an upper-classman, we lose. If Shyne doesn’t go off for 175, we lose. If Gay doesn’t give a Groza winner level performance, we lose.
I gave my vote to Shelley just because I was most worried about replacing Huntley, but all three of those guys won the game for us.