Wishnowsky ran a 4.4, Andy Philips trained for the Olympics, Matt Gay played college soccer, and Noyes competed in gymnastics in England and played Soccer and Rugby in HS. So, mostly I disagree.
Put this in your juice box and suck it: Noyes kicked 4 touch backs in the PAC 12 Championship game, was 6 for 8 on field goals in 2022 and 34 of 34 on PAT’s in 2022. He may not have been your ideal, but to tell a kid good riddance who gave all he had is a s**tty attitude to have. https://utahutes.com/sports/football/roster/jordan-noyes/13220
To be fair we don’t know that he did give all he had. Though I agree with your general point that he really wasn’t that bad. He wasn’t reliable on long-ish field goals, and wasn’t consistent with his kick-offs, but he was a serviceable kicker.
Good luck to the guy, but I’m pretty excited about our two newcomers & will be extremely relieved if between the two of them we can routinely get touchbacks.
I’m pretty optimistic we’ve upgraded significantly in our kicking-game.