Not all the All-American teams have been announced yet but some of those which have have Fano here:
CBS Sports: 2nd team
USA Today: 2nd team
PFF: 1st team
This from PFF:
Fano’s ability to maul defenders in the run game made him the most valuable FBS tackle, according to PFF’s wins above average metric. His 91.8 PFF run-blocking grade is more than three points better than any other offensive tackle in college football. The true sophomore is no slouch in pass protection, either, earning an 80.3 PFF grade in that aspect.
He’s already getting 1st round draft projections.