Scalley needs to be fired this year. Taylor and Whitt need to be given 2 more years. Harding needs to be given 1 more. If we don’t at least win the South by the end of 2019, it’s time to clean house. Whitt is a good coach but our ceiling with him is 8 or 9 wins.
Whit won 10 games just two years ago, so I disagree that his ceiling is 9 wins.
Also, if we give Taylor 2 more years, we are almost guaranteed to have 3 straight losing seasons. His offense is the worst we have had since Craig Ver Steeg or Tommy Lee.
Chow said on a radio interview this year, that when you start having issues with execution, pull the playbook back to the first plays you have installed in spring practice ; the ones you think should be the bread and butter of your offense.
Thumbs down all you want, but it is a bonafide FACT that we have not had an offense this bad since the Mcbride days. And that includes the Norm Chow offense with a D3 QB and a MWC roster our first year in the Pac-12. This offense is AWFUL.
Exceed expectations? Taylor isn’t even halfway to meeting expectations.
The offense is averaging 17.5 ppg over the last 4 games and 18.6 ppg against the 6 teams not named North Dakota or San Jose State.
I know we don’t want to get back on the OC carousel again, but what would be worse; keeping a god awful OC for another year or two hoping he improves or hiring a new OC again?
Come on guys give it time. This is only our 7th year in the Pac 12. Give it another 10 years then fire Whitt if he hasn’t won the South outright after 17 seasons.