I agree with everything you said Aloha. One thing to consider is Whitt has said he is ready to retire at anytime. Scalley has been hired to replace him. Essentially a lame duck coach. Now a losing season and some chaos in the program. Convincing good players to stay will be crucial. Scalley can promise a change on offense while maintaining the defense and overall culture.
I know they didn’t want yo lose Scalley but coach in waiting shouldn’t be more than 1 year. Recruits want to know who they will be playing for.